Fluffernutter Pie — Thanksgiving Pie Recipe Inspiration That’s Fun & Fast

Thanksgiving Pie Recipe Inspiration jumps off the page the moment you taste this pie — creamy marshmallow clouds meet rich peanut butter in a graham cracker cradle. If you love Peanut Butter Desserts, this no-bake Fluffernutter Pie will earn a permanent spot on your dessert table.

Introduction to the recipe

Imagine a cool, pillowy marshmallow filling that waltzes with velvety peanut butter atop a crunchy graham crust. Sound unreal? It isn’t. This pie assembles in minutes and chills into the kind of slice people fight over at family gatherings. Want something impressive but shockingly easy for Easy Pie Thanksgiving hosting? This is it.

What makes this pie so irresistible

Why does this combo work so well? Texture and nostalgia. You get:

• Pillowy marshmallow (light as air)
• Lush peanut butter (deep, nutty comfort)
• Crunchy graham crust (buttery contrast)
  Together, they hit sweet, salty, creamy, and crunchy in one forkful. Plus, it conjures childhood sandwich vibes but in grown-up pie form. Big tip: use real heavy cream and whip it to soft peaks — it keeps the filling airy and stable.

Ingredients (with quick notes)

Here’s the list I use when I want guaranteed smiles:

• Graham cracker crumbs: 1½ cups (about 10 full crackers smashed) — forms the crunchy base.
• Unsalted butter: 6 tablespoons, melted — binds and browns the crust.
• Mini marshmallows: 3 cups (or ~24 regular marshmallows if you don’t have minis) — the fluff heart of the pie.
• Heavy cream: 1½ cups (36–40% fat) — whip this into clouds for folding into the filling. Use heavy cream, not half-and-half.
• Creamy peanut butter: 1 cup — smooth is classic; use crunchy if you want texture.
• Whole milk: ¼ cup (optional; thins the peanut butter slightly if needed).
• Vanilla extract: 1 teaspoon — subtle lift.
• Salt: a pinch — pops the sweetness.
• Optional: chopped peanuts, chocolate shavings, or mini marshmallows for garnish.

Simple how-to (quick & clear)

Follow these steps and you’ll have a showy no-bake pie in under an hour (mostly chilling time):

1. Make the crust. Combine graham crumbs and melted butter in a bowl. Press firmly into a 9-inch pie plate, building a tidy edge. Chill 10 minutes to set.
2. Whip the cream. Beat heavy cream to soft peaks. Don’t overwhip; you want it billowy and foldable.
3. Melt the marshmallows. Gently warm the marshmallows with a splash of milk in a heatproof bowl over simmering water (double boiler) or microwave in 20-second bursts, stirring until smooth. Let cool slightly.
4. Blend peanut butter. Stir peanut butter with vanilla and a pinch of salt; add a touch of milk if it’s too stiff.
5. Fold it together. Fold marshmallow mixture into whipped cream, then gently swirl in the peanut butter until marbled and smooth. Keep it airy — don’t overmix.
6. Assemble & chill. Spoon the filling into the crust, smooth the top, and chill at least 2 hours until set. Garnish with chopped peanuts, chocolate, or extra marshmallows before serving.

Pro tip: If you want firm, sliceable pieces, chill overnight. If you crave immediate gratification, a well-chilled 2-hour set works great.

The story behind the pie

This pie traces its lineage to the beloved fluff-and-peanut-butter sandwich — a camp-lunch classic known as the fluffernutter. I transformed that nostalgic combo into a dessert you can plate at Thanksgiving. After I nailed the balance of marshmallow and peanut butter, I realized this incarnation ranks right up there with other crowd-pleasers like the S’more Pie Recipe and even rivals the textures of a Butterscotch Pecan Slab Pie (but lighter, IMO).

Pro tips for the best outcome (read these)

• Use real heavy cream. It whips better and keeps the filling airy.
• Don’t scorch the marshmallows. Melt them gently; overheating gives them a gummy texture.
• Spread the crust firmly. Press crumbs into the pan with the bottom of a measuring cup for a compact base that won’t crumble.
• Chill long enough. This pie improves with time — overnight is ideal for clean slices.
• Make it ahead. This one loves the fridge; it eases your holiday timeline.
• If the peanut butter seems too stiff, thin with a splash of milk. A tablespoon or two usually does the trick.

Bold tip: Toast a few chopped peanuts and sprinkle them on top just before serving for a crunchy contrast.

Variations to try (playful & delicious)

This pie is a blank canvas. Try these riffs:

• S’more twist: Add a chocolate ganache layer on the crust before adding the fluff—instant S’more Pie Recipe vibes.
• Chocolate-peanut swirl: Fold in ½ cup melted semi-sweet chocolate for marbled magic.
• Butterscotch-Pecan riff: Swap some peanut butter for butterscotch spread and top with pecans to echo a Butterscotch Pecan Slab Pie in mini form.
• Unbelievable Peanut Butter Pie upgrade: Add a thin layer of crushed peanut-butter-cup bits between crust and filling for an over-the-top Unbelievable Peanut Butter Pie experience.
• Individual servings: Build in ramekins or jars for single-serve Yummy Sweets at parties.

Best way to serve

Serve this pie chilled with a dollop of whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream. Want drama? Torch a few marshmallows on top for a caramelized finish. Pair it with coffee or a cold milk glass — both work like magic. If you serve at Thanksgiving, place it near other classics so guests can compare — it plays especially well beside fruit pies and denser nut pies.

Quick tips for storage & leftovers

• Refrigerate covered for up to 3–4 days.
• Freeze for longer storage: wrap tight and freeze up to 1 month; thaw overnight in fridge. Note: texture softens a bit after freezing.
• Revive the crunch: if you add nuts on top, store those separately and sprinkle before serving.

FAQs — your questions, answered

Final thoughts

If you crave Peanut Butter Desserts that feel nostalgic yet polished, this Fluffernutter Pie nails it. It sits comfortably next to classic holiday offerings, stands out on potluck tables, and earns high praise with minimal fuss. Whether you lean into the Unbelievable Peanut Butter Pie vibe, mash in a S’more Pie Recipe element, or keep it pure and simple, this dessert belongs in your recipe rotation.

Want more ideas? Try pairing slices with a tart berry compote to cut the richness, or serve tiny spoonfuls as party nibbles — folks will love the bite-sized Yummy Sweets approach. For those of you obsessed with peanut butter (no judgment), explore other Peanut Butter Recipes and stack flavors — this pie plays well with many.

Final bold tip: assemble this pie ahead, chill it well, and let it reward you with effortless applause at dessert time. Now go make that pie — and don’t forget to save me a slice.

Follow me on Pinterest for daily new recipes. Print